Okay, so you're on a second date. Things are going well. You sit down at a nice restaurant, scan the menu, and order a steak. Medium-rare. No sides. Just meat.

Your date orders a salad.

And then they say it: "You're really just eating...meat?"

Here's how to navigate dating while carnivore without coming off like a cult member or ending up in a 45-minute nutrition debate over tiramisu.

The First Date: Don't Lead With "I'm Carnivore"

Look, I get it. You're excited about carnivore. It changed your life. You want to share that.

But leading with your diet on a first date is like opening with your political affiliation or your feelings about pineapple on pizza. It's polarizing.

Instead, just order normally.

Pick a steakhouse or a place with good meat options. Order what you want. If they ask about sides, say, "I'm not that hungry" or "I'm saving room for dessert" (you won't order dessert, but they don't need to know that yet).

Most people won't notice or care. They're nervous about the date, not analyzing your plate.

If they ask directly:

"Oh, are you doing keto or something?"

Good responses:
  • "Yeah, low-carb. It works for me."
  • "I just feel better eating this way."
  • "I'm not big on carbs—energy crashes, you know?"

Keep it casual. Don't preach. Don't mention Paul Saladino or liver pills. Save that for month 3.

The Second/Third Date: They Notice

By date 2 or 3, they've seen you order steak twice. Or a burger, no bun. Or eggs and bacon for brunch.

They're going to ask.

The question:

"So...you only eat meat?"

Your response:

"Pretty much. I cut out most plant foods a while ago and feel way better. More energy, better focus, that kind of thing."

That's it. Don't spiral into a 20-minute lecture on oxalates and autoimmunity.

If they're curious:

"Oh interesting. What made you try that?"

Now you can elaborate a bit:

  • "I had some digestive issues that cleared up when I cut out grains and processed stuff."
  • "I wanted to simplify my diet and it just...works for me."
  • "I got into it through research on inflammation and elimination diets."

Frame it as your experience, not universal truth. People are way more receptive to "this works for me" than "this is the only correct way to eat."

If they're skeptical:

"But don't you need vegetables?"

Calm, non-defensive response:

"You'd think so, but I've been eating like this for [X months/years] and my labs are great. I feel good. It's weird, but it works."

Then change the subject. Don't defend. Don't argue. Just acknowledge their concern and move on.

The Early Relationship: Integration Strategies

You've been dating for a few weeks. They're starting to notice your routine:

  • You don't snack
  • You skip breakfast (or only have coffee)
  • You always order meat when you go out
  • Your fridge is just...meat and eggs

They might start asking more questions. Or worse, they might start worrying about you.

How to handle it: 1. Show them you're healthy

"I actually just got my bloodwork done. Everything's great—cholesterol, liver, kidneys, all normal. My doctor's happy."

Proof goes a long way. If your labs are good and you feel good, it's hard to argue.

2. Cook for them

Invite them over. Make an amazing carnivore meal:

  • Ribeye with herb butter
  • Bacon-wrapped shrimp
  • Crispy pork belly

Show them carnivore food isn't bland or restrictive. It's delicious.

Most people's objection to carnivore is "that sounds boring." When you serve them a perfectly cooked steak with crispy bacon and soft-scrambled eggs, they get it.

3. Don't force it on them

If they want to eat bread, let them. If they order pasta, don't comment.

Carnivore evangelism kills relationships. You do you. They do them. As long as they're not actively sabotaging you (hiding cookies in your car), it's fine.

The "You're Extreme" Conversation

At some point, they might say it:

"Don't you think this is a bit...extreme?"

This is the make-or-break moment. How you respond determines whether they accept your lifestyle or start planning an intervention.

Bad responses:
  • "Actually, eating plants is what's extreme. Humans are meant to eat meat."
  • "Do your research. Vegetables are toxic."
  • "The medical establishment is lying to you about nutrition."

These responses make you sound like you're in a cult.

Good responses:
  • "I get why it seems that way. But for me, it's actually the simplest way I've ever eaten. I don't count calories or macros. I just eat when I'm hungry."
  • "It feels extreme compared to the standard diet, but I'm healthier now than I was eating 'balanced meals.' So for me, it's working."
  • "I thought it was extreme at first too. But I tried it, felt better, and stuck with it. I don't expect everyone to get it."

The key: Acknowledge their concern without being defensive.

You're not trying to convert them. You're just explaining that this works for you.

The Restaurant Dilemma: Where to Eat

Carnivore limits your restaurant options. This can be annoying for your date, especially if they're vegetarian or vegan (in which case, good luck).

Best carnivore-friendly date spots:

1. Steakhouses (obvious choice)

  • You: Ribeye, no sides
  • Them: Whatever they want
  • No awkwardness

2. Brazilian steakhouses (churrascarias)

  • All-you-can-eat meat
  • They can get the salad bar if they want
  • Perfect for carnivores
3. BBQ joints
  • Brisket, ribs, sausage
  • Easy to skip the coleslaw and beans
  • Casual vibe, no pressure
4. Breakfast/brunch spots
  • Eggs, bacon, sausage everywhere
  • They can get pancakes, you get a steak and eggs
  • Works for both of you
5. Burger places (not fast food)
  • Order a bunless burger with extra patties
  • Most places will do it without blinking
  • Casual, low-pressure
Places to avoid on early dates:
  • Vegan restaurants (for obvious reasons)
  • Italian (pasta-heavy, awkward to navigate)
  • Sushi (you can do sashimi, but it's pricey and weird to order 12 pieces of salmon while they get a California roll)

The "What If They're Vegan?" Problem

You're carnivore. They're vegan. This is a disaster waiting to happen.

Can it work?

Short-term? Maybe. You both respect each other's choices and don't talk about food.

Long-term? Probably not.

Here's why:

  • Shared meals are a huge part of relationships
  • Cooking together becomes impossible
  • Your values around food are diametrically opposed
  • One of you will eventually try to convert the other

My advice: If you're serious about carnivore and they're serious about veganism, have the conversation early. Don't waste 6 months trying to make it work.

Exception: If they're vegan for ethical reasons but open-minded about health, there's room for dialogue. If they're dogmatic ("eating meat is murder"), cut your losses.

Living Together: The Fridge Situation

You move in together. Now your carnivore lifestyle is fully visible.

Your half of the fridge:
  • Ground beef
  • Ribeyes
  • Eggs
  • Bacon
  • Butter
Their half:
  • Vegetables
  • Fruit
  • Bread
  • Pasta
  • Normal human food

This can actually work if you set boundaries:

1. You cook your meals, they cook theirs

Don't expect them to cook carnivore for you. Don't force them to eat what you're eating.

Parallel meal prep. You grill a steak, they make pasta. Sit down and eat together. It's fine.

2. Respect each other's food

They don't mess with your meat. You don't lecture them about seed oils.

3. Find overlap meals

Some meals work for both:

  • Steak dinner: You eat steak. They eat steak + roasted veggies.
  • Breakfast: You have bacon and eggs. They have eggs and toast.
  • Burgers: You eat bunless. They eat with a bun.

You don't have to eat identical meals. Just eat together.

The Family Dinner Trap

You've been dating for 6 months. It's time to meet the parents.

And of course, mom made lasagna.

What do you do? Option 1: Eat before you go

Have a big carnivore meal before the dinner. When you get there, take a small portion of whatever's being served, push it around your plate, and say you're not that hungry.

This avoids confrontation and doesn't make you the center of attention.

Option 2: Be honest (politely)

"Thanks so much for cooking. I actually eat pretty differently these days—mostly just meat and eggs. It's helped with some health stuff. Is it okay if I just have the [meat portion of the meal]?"

Most parents will accommodate. They might think you're weird, but they'll respect the honesty.

Option 3: Bring your own food

If it's a casual family BBQ or potluck, bring a tray of ribeyes or burgers. Grill them up. Share with anyone who wants to try.

This works surprisingly well. People love good meat.

What NOT to do:
  • Lecture the family about nutrition ("Actually, that bread is toxic")
  • Refuse to eat anything and sit there awkwardly
  • Make your diet the focal point of the meal

You're there to connect, not convert.

The Long-Term Relationship: Acceptance or Resentment?

If you've been together for a year or more and you're still carnivore, one of two things has happened:

Scenario 1: They've accepted it

They don't care that you eat only meat. They've seen your bloodwork, you feel great, and it's just part of who you are. They might even eat carnivore meals with you occasionally.

This is the goal.

Scenario 2: They resent it

They think you're extreme. They worry about your health. They make passive-aggressive comments about your diet. They try to sneak vegetables onto your plate.

This relationship has an expiration date.

How to tell which scenario you're in: Acceptance:
  • They don't comment on your food choices
  • They support you getting bloodwork and tracking health metrics
  • They don't try to change you
  • They're fine cooking separately or eating together
Resentment:
  • They make jokes about your diet in front of friends
  • They send you articles about "the dangers of red meat"
  • They pressure you to "just try" carbs or vegetables
  • They roll their eyes when you order steak

If you're in Scenario 2, you need to have a serious conversation. Either they accept your choices, or the relationship won't work.

The Bottom Line

Dating on carnivore isn't that hard. You just need to:

1. Don't lead with it on first dates. Order normally. Ease them in.

2. Frame it as your choice, not universal truth. "This works for me" beats "this is the only way."

3. Show, don't preach. Cook amazing carnivore meals. Share your bloodwork. Let results speak.

4. Don't force it on them. They can eat what they want. You eat what you want.

5. Find restaurants that work for both of you. Steakhouses, BBQ, brunch spots.

6. Set boundaries in shared living. Separate meal prep, mutual respect.

And if they can't accept your diet? They're not the right person.

You don't need someone who eats exactly like you. You need someone who respects your choices and doesn't try to change you.

That's the real test.

---

Community Input:

From r/carnivorediet:

  • u/SteakAndEggs87: "I've been carnivore for 2 years. My girlfriend thinks it's weird, but she doesn't care as long as I'm healthy. We cook separately and eat together. It's fine."
  • u/MeatheadMike: "First date, she ordered a Caesar salad. I ordered 3 burgers, no buns. She laughed. We're married now."
  • u/KetoKatie: "I tried dating a vegan once. It lasted 3 weeks. Don't do it."