Okay, so you've decided to go carnivore. Great. But now you have to tell your family.
And your family eats pasta. And bread. And vegetables. And dessert.
How do you do carnivore without becoming the weird one at Thanksgiving dinner or starting a nutrition argument every time someone offers you a cookie?
Here are the strategies that actually work.
Strategy 1: Don't Announce It
The biggest mistake carnivore beginners make: telling everyone they're carnivore.
You don't need to announce your diet like it's a religious conversion. Just...eat differently.
What not to do:> "Family, I have an announcement. I'm going carnivore. From now on, I'm only eating meat. No more pasta, bread, or vegetables. I've done my research and this is the healthiest way to eat."
This makes you sound preachy and invites debate.
What to do instead:Just eat meat. Don't explain unless asked.
At dinner, take the meat portion. Skip the sides. No one will notice at first.
If someone asks:
> "You're not having potatoes?"
Calm response:"Nah, I'm good. Not that hungry."
That's it. Don't launch into a lecture about insulin resistance.
---
Strategy 2: The Stealth Carnivore Approach
This works if you live with family or eat with them regularly.
How it works:You quietly eat carnivore without making it a thing. You order steak at restaurants. You make eggs for breakfast. You skip the bread basket.
Most people won't notice for weeks. And when they do notice, they'll just think you're "eating healthy" or "doing low-carb."
Example:Your family makes spaghetti for dinner. You:
1. Eat the meatballs
2. Skip the pasta
3. Add extra meat to your plate
4. Say you're full if anyone asks why you're not eating pasta
No confrontation. No nutrition debate. You just quietly do your thing.
When this works:- Your family doesn't pay close attention to what you eat
- You're independent enough to cook your own meals
- You're not the type to preach about diet
- Your mom notices everything and will interrogate you
- You eat family-style meals where everyone shares the same food
- Someone in your family is a nutritionist and will have opinions
---
Strategy 3: The "I'm Trying Something for My Health" Frame
If your family notices you're eating differently, frame it as a health intervention, not a lifestyle choice.
What to say:> "I've been dealing with some digestive issues, so I'm doing an elimination diet to figure out what's bothering me."
Or:
> "My doctor suggested I try cutting out processed foods and focusing on whole foods. I'm seeing how I feel."
Or:
> "I've been reading about inflammation and I'm experimenting with reducing carbs. Just seeing if it helps with my energy levels."
Why this works:Framing it as "for my health" makes it sound temporary and medical, not ideological.
People are less likely to argue with "I'm trying to fix a health issue" than "I'm carnivore now and vegetables are toxic."
When to use this:- Early in your carnivore journey (first 3 months)
- If your family is skeptical of alternative diets
- If you want to avoid conflict
- If you're planning to do carnivore long-term and eventually want to be open about it
- If your family will call you out for lying when they realize it's been 6 months and you're still "experimenting"
---
Strategy 4: The Parallel Meal Prep System
This is the best long-term solution if you live with family.
How it works:You cook your carnivore meals. They cook their meals. You eat together, but different food.
Example:Family is making tacos.
- They make: taco shells, ground beef, salsa, cheese, lettuce
- You make: 1 lb of taco-seasoned ground beef in a separate pan
Everyone sits down together. They eat tacos. You eat a bowl of seasoned ground beef.
Why this works:You're still participating in family meals. You're just eating different food.
No one feels excluded. No one has to change their diet for you. It's parallel, not separate.
Tips for parallel meal prep:- Cook your meat at the same time they're cooking dinner
- Eat at the table with them (don't isolate yourself)
- Don't comment on their food or try to convert them
- Keep your food simple so it's not extra work
- You have time to cook your own meals
- Your family is okay with you eating differently
- You're not trying to force carnivore on anyone else
- Your family takes it personally if you don't eat their cooking
- You're too busy to cook separate meals
- You're financially dependent and can't afford separate groceries
---
Strategy 5: The "Just the Protein, Please" Hack
This works for family dinners where someone else is cooking.
How it works:You eat the meat portion of every meal and politely decline the sides.
Examples: Thanksgiving:- Eat: Turkey, ham, any meat
- Skip: Stuffing, mashed potatoes, rolls, cranberry sauce
- Say: "I'm saving room for seconds of turkey!"
- Eat: Roast beef, pork chops
- Skip: Potatoes, carrots, bread
- Say: "I'm really hungry for protein today."
- Eat: Burgers (no bun), ribs, sausage, chicken
- Skip: Coleslaw, potato salad, buns
- Say: "I'm doing low-carb right now."
You're still eating the main dish. You're not rejecting the meal entirely. You're just skipping sides.
Most families won't care if you don't eat the green beans. They care if you don't eat what they cooked.
Eating the meat = showing respect for their effort.
When this works:- Family meals are meat-heavy
- Your family doesn't force you to eat specific foods
- You can deflect questions with "I'm full" or "I'm low-carb"
- Your family is vegetarian (no meat to eat)
- Your family takes it personally if you don't eat everything
- The meal is pasta-heavy or grain-based (nothing for you to eat)
---
Strategy 6: The Potluck Contribution
If your family does potluck-style meals, bring your own carnivore dish.
How it works:You show up with a tray of meat. You eat mostly your dish. No one cares because everyone brought food.
Examples: BBQ potluck:- Bring: 3 lbs of ribeyes, pre-seasoned
- Grill them up
- Eat mostly your steaks, maybe try a bite of someone else's dish
- Bring: Bacon-wrapped shrimp or beef skewers
- Everyone loves your dish
- You eat your contribution + any other meat at the table
You're contributing to the meal, so no one can accuse you of being difficult.
Your dish is meat-based, so you have something to eat.
And chances are, other people will eat your dish too. Everyone loves bacon-wrapped shrimp.
When this works:- Family does potluck-style gatherings
- You're willing to cook and bring food
- You want to share carnivore food with others
- Family does sit-down dinners where one person cooks everything
- You don't have time or budget to bring extra food
---
The "You're Extreme" Conversation (And How to Handle It)
At some point, someone will say it:
> "Aren't you being a bit extreme?"
Bad responses:- "No, eating plants is extreme. Humans are carnivores."
- "Actually, vegetables are toxic. Do your research."
- "The medical establishment is lying to you."
These responses make you sound like a cult member.
Good responses:> "I get why it seems that way. But it's actually the simplest diet I've ever done. I just eat when I'm hungry and I feel great."
> "It might seem extreme, but for me, it's working. I have more energy, better focus, and my labs are good."
> "I thought it was extreme at first too. But I tried it, felt better, and stuck with it."
The key: Acknowledge their concern without being defensive.You're not trying to convert them. You're just explaining that this works for you.
---
The "What About Nutrients?" Conversation
Someone at the table will inevitably ask:
> "But don't you need vegetables for vitamins?"
Calm, non-confrontational response:"I get my nutrients from meat. Beef has B12, zinc, iron, and most vitamins. I also eat liver occasionally for vitamin A and other nutrients. My bloodwork is good."
If they push back:> "But what about fiber?"
"I don't need fiber. My digestion is actually better without it."
Don't:- Lecture them about anti-nutrients in plants
- Send them links to carnivore research papers
- Turn it into a debate
- Answer calmly and briefly
- Change the subject
- Let them think you're weird (you don't need their approval)
---
The "I'm Worried About You" Conversation
If your parents or close family members are genuinely worried, handle it differently.
What they might say:> "I'm really concerned about your health. This seems dangerous."
How to respond:> "I appreciate your concern. I'm tracking my health closely. I've had bloodwork done and everything's normal. If anything changes, I'll see a doctor."
Follow-up actions:- Show them your lab results (if they're good)
- Explain that you're monitoring your health
- Reassure them that you're not ignoring medical advice
- Get defensive or angry
- Dismiss their concern
- Refuse to discuss it
They care about you. They're scared because carnivore is unconventional. Give them reassurance.
---
The Kids Question: "Should I Make My Kids Carnivore?"
This is touchy. Here's my take:
If your kids have health issues (eczema, ADHD, autoimmune issues):Carnivore might help. But work with a doctor. Kids need proper nutrition for growth.
If your kids are healthy:Don't force it. Let them eat a normal diet. If they're interested in trying carnivore meals, great. If not, don't push it.
What most carnivore parents do:They eat carnivore. Their kids eat a mix of carnivore meals and standard kid food.
Example:
- Breakfast: You eat bacon and eggs. Kids eat bacon, eggs, and toast.
- Lunch: Kids eat school lunch. You eat steak.
- Dinner: You all eat steak. Kids add a side of pasta or rice.
Kids get exposure to carnivore meals without feeling restricted. They eat what works for them. No one's forcing anything.
---
The Bottom Line
You can do carnivore in a family that eats standard American diet. You just need to:
1. Don't announce it like a lifestyle change. Just eat differently.
2. Frame it as a health experiment if people ask.
3. Use parallel meal prep. You cook your food, they cook theirs.
4. Eat the meat portion of every family meal and skip the sides.
5. Bring carnivore dishes to potlucks.
6. Don't preach or convert. Let your results speak.
And if someone gives you a hard time, remember: You don't need their approval.
You're eating this way because it works for you. That's enough.
---
Community Input:From r/carnivorediet:
> "I've been carnivore for 2 years. My family still thinks it's weird, but they've stopped commenting. They just know I eat meat and that's it." — u/MeatEater2024
> "Thanksgiving was easy. I ate turkey and ham. Skipped everything else. No one cared." — u/ThanksgivingCarnivore
> "My mom was worried for the first 6 months. Then I showed her my bloodwork. She stopped nagging." — u/BloodworkProof